'Moral responsibility': Barbara Hewson, a prominent barrister, suggested some victims may be partly responsible for being raped
Rape victims can be partly responsible for what happened to them, according to a leading lawyer.
Barbara
Hewson, a human rights and civil liberties barrister at London's
Hardwicke Chambers, challenged the idea that 'the victim is utterly
innocent and the victimiser is utterly guilty'.
Miss
Hewson, who describes herself on Twitter as 'not for the easily
offended', suggested that people who are raped can have a 'moral
responsibility' for the crime, even though the law says that rape is
only ever the fault of the rapist.
She also questioned whether 'claims of victimisation must always be respected', according to The Daily Telegraph.
Miss
Hewson, 52, made the comments during a debate with other legal
professionals at the London School of Economics on Wednesday, entitled
'Is Rape Different?'
She said: 'We need to make a distinction between legal responsibility and moral responsibility.
'The
law does not attribute any responsibility now to the victim of rape
whereas traditionally we know the judge would say when they came to
sentence "well she was contributorally [sic] negligent" or something
like that.'
While outlining
what she views as the received wisdom when discussing, Miss Hewson
dismissed the idea 'that it's morally absolutely unambiguous,
the victim is utterly innocent and the victimiser is utterly guilty and
this is infinitesimal. And finally that claims of victimisation must
always be respected, anything less is victim-blaming.'
Miss Hewson compared a rape victim to
somebody who falls over whilst drunk to demonstrate that people can put
themselves in a situation where they are more likely to fall victim to a
crime.
She also attacked a
culture around rape which encourages people to 'realise' they have been
raped, and added that some victims go on to blame their ordeal for
everything that goes wrong in their life.
Rape Crisis spokesman Fiona Elvines
condemned Miss Hewson's argument, telling the Telegraph: 'Barbara
Hewson shows how out of touch she is with the realities of sexual
violence. As a society, we have moved on from the rape myths she
continues to propagate.'
Miss
Hewson, a Cambridge graduate who has worked as a barrister since 1985,
has courted controversy on sexual offences before, by attacking the
decision to double the sentence for broadcaster Stuart Hall.
His original sentence of 15 months in prison for 14 counts of indecent assault was increased to 30 months after a public outcry.
She
has also previously called for the age of consent to be lowered to 13
and criticised the 'witch-hunt' of ageing celebrities accused of sexual
abuse.
Miss Hewson was unavailable for comment this morning.
A LAW UNTO HERSELF: THE CONTROVERSIAL BARRISTER WHO'S NOT AFRAID TO SPEAK HER MIND
Barbara
Hewson has made a name for herself both as one of the country's most
respected lawyers, and as someone not afraid to ruffle some feathers
with her outspoken views.
A
member of the prestigious Hardwicke Chambers, Miss Hewson, who was
called to the bar in 1985, is regularly ranked in the Legal 500
directory.
She has won a
Barrister of the Year award from The Lawyer magazine after she fought
for the rights of pregnant women against compulsory treatment.
The
Chambers UK guide has variously described her as ‘bright, committed and
passionate’, ‘well-respected’, ‘highly diplomatic’ and ‘a tough
opponent’.
She writes on legal issues for the Spiked website, and is often highly critical of the establishment.
Miss Hewson has stepped into the firing line on numerous occasions in the past.
Responding
to the controversial case in which a judge described a 13-year-old sex
attack victim as ‘predatory’, she tweeted: ‘It takes two to tango.
Disgusting tho' these men are, frankly the girls are often not much
better - and no shrieking martyrs.'
She
has also said that operation Yewtree, into sex abuse linked to Jimmy
Savile, ‘has got out of hand’ and was hijacked by ‘moral crusaders’.
A
storm of criticism met that suggestion, and she has also angered the
NPCC by suggesting at the same time that the age of consent be lowered
to 13.
At the time an NSPCC
spokesman said: ‘To trivialise the impact of these offences for victims
is all but denying they have suffered abuse at all.’
dailymail.co.uk
No comments:
Post a Comment