Two foreign rioters jailed for their
part in England's civil unrest two years ago have foiled attempts to
deport them by citing their human right to 'family life'.
The
successful appeals by Ubong-Luke Nkanta, of south-east London, and a
second man, who has been granted anonymity, defy the Government's pledge
to deport any foreign national convicted over the 2011 disturbances.
Critics
say the decisions sharply contradict official efforts to take exemplary
action against those involved in the outbreaks of violence in London
and elsewhere that summer.
A Carpetright store burns on Tottenham High Road
on August 6, 2011: Two foreign rioters jailed for their part in the
civil unrest have foiled attempts to deport them by citing their human
right to 'family life'
Government anger over the use of
Article Eight of the Human Rights Act, which enshrines the right to a
family life, has prompted Home Secretary Theresa May to draft new laws
to stop foreign criminals avoiding deportation.
Ministers
believe judges will be unable to ignore the new legislation, as they
appear to have ignored rules introduced last July that they should only
allow the use of Article Eight in 'exceptional circumstances'.
Immigration Minister Mark Harper said
today: 'Any foreign national who abuses the privilege of coming to the
UK by committing a serious offence should face the consequences.
'Many of those convicted of involvement in the 2011 summer's riots are still behind bars - that's where they belong.
'We
are pursuing deportation in scores of cases and wherever possible we
will remove them from the UK — regardless of whether they have family
here.
'We are disappointed
with this judgment and that is why this Government will bring forward
primary legislation to prevent foreign nationals remaining in the UK
through abuse of the Human Rights Act.
'We
are also looking at appeals to make sure that foreign nationals cannot
misuse the legal system and the courts in bids to stay in the country.'
A youth films rioters throwing missiles at
police lines on August 8, 2011: Government anger over the use of the
Human Rights Act has prompted Theresa May to draft new laws to stop
foreign criminals using it
A masked rioter is seen dragging a bin in to
make barricades in Hackney: More than 200 foreign criminals were
convicted for their part in the riots in which hundreds of millions of
pounds of damage was done
The latest cases, reported in the Sunday Telegraph, highlight the arguments used which are causing the Home Office such frustration.
In
the first case, Nigerian-born Ubong-Luke Nkanta, from Thamesmead, was
in November 2011 jailed for 18 months for burglary during the riots in
London.
The 25-year-old
entered a building which was being looted by rioters but did not steal
anything because, he told the court, 'there was nothing left to take'.
The
Home Office began deportation proceedings against him as he approached
his release from jail last summer, but he appealed against the move by
citing his 'right to a family life'.
He
argued his relationship with his two biological children in the UK as
well as his current partner's children meant his human rights would be
breached if he was deported.
The
lower immigration tribunal agreed and, following an appeal by the Home
Office, the decision was upheld by Upper Immigration Tribunal Judge
Isabel Murray.
The second
case is of a Zimbabwean who can only be named as 'TS' after senior
immigration judges granted him anonymity - despite the fact criminal
courts had allowed him to be named.
He
was convicted of violent disorder and jailed for 15 months after
joining a group of 30 to 50 youths who rampaged through two
Buckinghamshire towns in copy cat riots three days after the initial
outbreak of violence in Tottenham.
The
gang, which was later described in court as a 'mindless mob', swept
through Milton Keynes and Bletchley launching attacks on vehicles and
shops, including a Chinese takeaway whose owners were robbed of their
takings.
TS was identified
as one of the main culprits who launched an attack on a bus which left
its driver 'frightened for her life' as they kicked the vehicle and
pelted it with rocks.
A masked youth during riots in Hackney, London:
Both the rioters in today's story were granted the right to remain in
the country based on their right to a family life under Article Eight of
the Human Rights Act
Ministers had pledged to take
tough action to kick out foreign criminals as quickly as possible after
the riots in August 2011 which began in Tottenham, north London and
spread across the country into several nights of carnage.
More than 200 foreign criminals were
convicted for their part in the riots in which shops were plundered,
businesses set ablaze and hundreds of millions of pounds of damage done.
Home Office minister Damian Green said
at the time: ‘We strongly believe that foreign national lawbreakers
should be removed from the UK at the earliest opportunity.
‘We
also have the power to cancel visas of foreign nationals found guilty
of criminal activity, and this is something we will be looking to do
when these cases arise.’
In
the following months, it emerged that non-UK nationals played a central
role in the mayhem. Figures from the courts showed one in seven of all
convicted rioters was from overseas.
The
Ministry of Justice released a list showing 44 nationalities of
convicted rioters, including those from Afghanistan, Cuba, Ethiopia and
Samoa.
The largest group was
Jamaicans, followed by Somali and Polish offenders. Other rioters came
from Colombia, Iraq, the Congo, Vietnam and Zimbabwe.
DAILYMAIL
No comments:
Post a Comment